Plumbing • Heating • Gas
(718) 767-0707

Cost to Install a Water Heater in New York

November 09, 2025


Water heater installation costs in New York tend to vary widely based on several factors. This guide breaks down key information so you can make an informed decision and choose the right company for the job, including:

  • What factors determine the cost of a water heater installation in New York
  • Comparing tank vs. tankless water heaters: which is more affordable?
  • Key costs to expect during installation
  • How to choose the right water heater for your home
  • The value of professional installation

Remember to weigh your options carefully before making any final decisions.


Reliable Water Heater Installation in New York — Contact Ranshaw Today!

Tired of running out of hot water? Schedule your new water heater installation with Ranshaw for honest pricing and peace of mind that the job will get done right the first time.


Schedule Estimate

What Factors Determine the Cost of a Water Heater Installation in New York?

Your expected water heater installation cost in NY depends on factors such as:

  • Unit price. Generally speaking, tank water heaters cost less than tankless models. Gas models tend to cost more than electric ones.
  • Labor. The cost of labor for water heater installs in NY tends to be higher than national averages. That’s because the cost of living tends to be much higher in urban locations, especially in the NYC area.
  • On-site challenges. If your new water heater will be installed in a hard-to-access area, or your home requires retrofitting or upgrades to plumbing and/or venting to support the new water heater, the job may take longer, resulting in a higher installation cost.
  • Permits and inspections. Some municipalities implement strict permitting and inspection requirements for water heater installations. These requirements serve to enforce stringent safety standards, and help prevent gas leaks from faulty installations. Issuing permits can involve additional costs.

Comparing Tank vs. Tankless Water Heaters: Which Is More Affordable?

Traditional tank water heaters tend to be more affordable than tankless models. They’re ideal for most homes with moderate hot water demands. However, they offer a limited supply of hot water compared to their tankless counterparts.

Tankless water heaters on the other hand provide an unlimited supply of hot water, however they cost more upfront and to maintain. Installing this type of water heater can require changes to plumbing, venting and electrical setups. Repairs also tend to cost more for tankless systems.

How to Choose the Right Water Heater for Your Home

Choosing the right water heater requires careful consideration. Your plumber should be more than happy to walk you through choosing the right water heater for your home. However, to get started, consider these points:

  • Household size. Larger families tend to benefit from bigger tanks or tankless systems. If you live alone, you can probably get by with a smaller tank model.
  • Budget considerations. Opting for a traditional tank water heater is the least expensive option in the long run, even when factoring in the efficiency of a tankless unit. The higher cost of equipment/installation as well as maintenance and repair costs, can easily offset the high efficiency operating savings and then some.
  • Convenience. If features like a continuous supply of hot water and a greater control of temperature are more important than cost, tankless is the way to go.
  • Space availability. If you have limited space, tankless systems provide a more compact solution than tank systems.

The Value of Professional Installation

Your water heater installation should always be performed by a skilled professional. Professionals know exactly how to get your new water heater installed safely and ensure compliance with all local codes. Their experience helps minimize the risk of costly errors while also optimizing the system's performance and lifespan.


Need a New Water Heater? Ranshaw Has You Covered!

Trust the pros with a 4.8/5-star rating on Google and over 60 years of experience with water heater installation. Our trained technicians are punctual and can get your new water heater running in no time.

Schedule Estimate

Similar Articles:

Serving the NYC metro area, including:

And everywhere in between!